Caitlyn Olson

Wolf Humanities Center Regional Fellow

20252026 Forum on Truth

Caitlyn Olson

Assistant Professor of Islamic Studies, Department of Religious Studies, Bucknell University

Caitlyn Olson is a historian of Islamic northwest Africa between the 14th-18th centuries. Her work focuses on Islamic intellectual history, in particular rational theology, as well as on dynamics between educated, elite religious authorities and members of the broader Muslim populace. These interests are currently taking the form of a monograph titled Creed for the Common Folk: Orthodoxy and Elitism in Early Modern Morocco. Related to that project, Caitlyn is also working on a critical edition of Arabic writings by a 17th-century scholar of southeast Morocco named Muhammad b. ʿUmar b. Abi Mahalli. Having earned her PhD from Harvard, Caitlyn is the Josephine Hildreth Detmer and Zareen Taj Mirza Assistant Professor of Islamic Studies at Bucknell University.

Managing Theological Truth in Early Modern Morocco

This first monograph is entitled Creed for the Common Folk: Orthodoxy and Elitism in Early Modern Morocco. The book analyzes discussions among Moroccan scholars between the 14th-18th centuries around how to conceptualize and manage the religious belief of less educated Muslims. The project will show that while these scholars broadly agreed on the importance of belief, as well as on core doctrine, they disagreed over whether it is necessary, ethical, or even feasible to assess others’ internal cognitive states and attempt to shape their beliefs. In short, the project comprises a historical study of how scholarly elites in a particular time and place articulated theological truths and sought to ensure adherence to those truths in wider society. Alongside the monograph, the project will also include a critical edition of Arabic writings by Muhammad b. ʿUmar b. Abi Mahalli, a 17th-century scholar of southeast Morocco who was especially insistent on the need to intervene in the beliefs of others.